Stop Buying Fancy Toys: What Your Niece or Nephew Actually Craves

As a loving aunt, it is one of the greatest joys to walk into a toy store and imagine the look on your niece or nephew’s face when you give them that bright, noisy, all-the-bells-and-whistles toy. We all want to be the aunt who gives the best gifts.

But have you ever noticed that the baby often seems more interested in the wrapping paper? Or that their favorite “toy” is a set of plastic measuring cups from the kitchen? That is a huge clue. They are trying to tell you that what an aunt’s niece or nephew actually craves is not another “thing.” It is something far simpler and more powerful: human connection.

The Craving for Connection (Not Gadgets)

What your niece or nephew actually craves is simple, human connection. They are not built to be impressed by expensive gadgets. They are hardwired to seek out rhythm, loving attention, and responsive social interaction with the people they trust. Your presence is always more interesting than a present.

A fancy toy is a one-way street. It flashes and makes noise, but it cannot respond to the baby’s coos or smile back. It is just stimulation. A real, loving interaction is a two-way street that builds their brain and their heart. In my book, Auntie of the Year, I make this distinction clear:

“Babies don’t need fancy toys or big gestures. They crave connection, rhythm, and loving attention.”

“Connection” is that back-and-forth play. “Rhythm” is the comfort of your voice. “Loving attention” is the feeling of being seen. These are the three things that a baby is looking for in every single interaction.

3 Simple Ways to Give Them What They Crave

You use the most powerful tools you have, which are all 100% free: your voice, your face, and your touch. These are the “toys” that a baby’s brain is designed to love, and they are the key to a deep bonding connection.

Here is how to turn simple moments into rich bonding experiences:

1. Use Your Voice (Rhythm): A baby is fascinated by the rhythm of your speech. Sing a simple song like “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” or narrate what you are doing. “Let’s put on your blue socks. One foot… and the other foot!” This rhythmic sound provides sensory engagement that is incredibly soothing.
2. Use Your Face (Connection): Your face is the most interesting thing in the room. Get down to their eye level and play simple games like peekaboo. This face-to-face connection allows them to mimic you and learn how to have a “conversation.”
3. Use Your Touch (Loving Attention): Gentle, rhythmic touch is a powerful connector. When you are holding them, gently pat their back in a steady rhythm or play “This Little Piggy” with their toes. As we discuss in Why a 20-Minute Visit is Better Than a 3-Hour Stay, this physical connection makes them feel safe and loved.

Does This Mean I Should Never Buy Gifts?

Of course not. Giving gifts is a joyful part of being an aunt. This is not about guilt; it is about perspective. The gift is just the bonus. You are the main event.

The goal is to shift your mindset. Instead of seeing the toy as the gift, see the toy as a tool for connection. The best “toys” are those that encourage open-ended play, like blocks or stacking rings, because they require you to be part of the fun. The real “gift” happens when you sit on the floor, cheering them on.

Curious about which toys are best? Experts at Zero to Three explain why simple toys that spark imagination are often better than flashy electronics.

Frequently Asked Questions

---

---